

Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 32 hours and 2 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: Macmillan Audio
Audible.com Release Date: November 24, 2004
Language: English
ASIN: B0006SJ2G4
Best Sellers Rank: #41 in Books > Literature & Fiction > Genre Fiction > Historical > Fantasy #62 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Fantasy #212 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Fiction & Literature

I'm giving Jonathan Strange a 5 for the simply reason that I thoroughly enjoyed it all the way through, but I'd warn all readers to be more wary than usual of reviews (including this one). More than many books, this one I think will be a matter of true personal taste and experience will be your only truly accurate guide. To begin with, Strange is often referred to as a "fantasy" novel, an "adult" Harry Potter (ignoring Potter's self-obvious claim to millions of "adult" readers). If you're expecting fantasy in the form of Harry Potter magic (though done by bigger people employing bigger words) or Lord of the Rings-like quests and elves, be advised neither is here. Fantastical might be a better genre-word here than "fantasy". There is certainly magic here, both human and faerie (very different forms), but when one of the major storylines is how magic has gradually disappeared from England and when one of the major characters has as his purpose the destruction (not Black Tower hordes of evil monsters destruction but economic, social, or legal destruction) of those who would become magician, as you might imagine there isn't a lot of magic going on, at least not for the first few hundred pages. Those looking for a lot of wand-waving or fireball-flinging would best look elsewhere. One of the signs of the book's maturity is that one can't really generalize too much about the magic in it. Magic is almost invisible in the beginning and near-constant toward the end. It is scholarly, bookish and tedious and also vigorous, physical and exciting. It is human and Faerie and a melding of the two. It is all-powerful (Spain complains about the rearrangement of several of their country's geographic landmarks) and ineffective (you can see visions in water but they seldom are helpful).
This book is hard to describe. In terms of genre, it is both fantasy and well-researched historical fiction, which makes it a rather rare bird. The writing style falls somewhere between Austen and Gaiman and Dickens. The plot is somewhat rambling and disjoint, forsaking the standard quest narratives; in some ways it is a fantastic history of England, in some ways a tale of rescue. If it is anything, it is the story of the relationship between the two title characters, but one of them is not even introduced for two hundred pages.. Unlike most of the better modern fantasy, this book is not a page-turner, and I mean that as a compliment; rather, it is a book to savor. Not that the plot isn't engaging - it is - but I frequently found myself comparing how many pages I'd read to how many I had left, deciding that I was burning through the book too quickly, and setting it down while I turned the passages I'd just read over in my head. As befits a character-driven fantasy, almost all the characters are likeable, or at least understandable; even when they take larger-than-life action, they do so for incredibly human reasons. There are also a number of historical-character cameos, all of them well-drawn and believable.. I do not agree with Mr. Gaiman's statement that this is "the finest English novel of the fantasticke to appear in the past 70 years." Tolkien is better; his work has an epic grandeur that this book lacks, perhaps because Susanna Clarke so realistically and concretely evokes the precise historical era at which she aims : the imagination has a somewhat wider canvas to paint on when reading Tolkien or similar high fantasy, with more blank space to be filled in by the reader.
Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell: A Novel Jonathan Goes to the Doctor (Jonathan Adventures) Jonathan Park Volume IX: The Whispering Sphinx (Jonathan Park Radio Drama) (MP3) Jonathan Park: The Copper Scroll (Jonathan Park Radio Drama) High Treason: A Jonathan Grave Thriller, Book 5 Art of Jonathan Green 2016 Calendar 11x14 2014 Art of Jonathan Green The Art of Jonathan Green 2013 Calendar The Art of Jonathan Green Calendar Jonathan Taylor Thomas (Gos) (Galaxy of Superstars) Jonathan Edwards (Christian Biographies for Young Readers) The Spirit of Revival: Discovering the Wisdom of Jonathan Edwards Best of Jonathan Edwards Sermons Jonathan Edwards: A Life The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evangelical Tradition Dr. Jonathan V. Wright's Nutrition & Healing (The skin cancer cure... yes, cure... that works every time, Volume 14 Number 5) Dr. Jonathan V. Wright's Nutrition & Healing (Abnormal Pap Smear and Heavy Menstrual Bleeding, Volume 2 Number 11) Jonathan Livingston Seagull: The Complete Edition The Notorious Elizabeth Tuttle: Marriage, Murder, and Madness in the Family of Jonathan Edwards (North American Religions)