Free Downloads Does The Frontier Experience Make America Exceptional? (Historians At Work)
Does the frontier experience make America exceptional? When Frederick Jackson Turner presented this idea in 1893 as the core of his now-famous thesis, he set in motion a debate that historians of the American West have contended with ever since. The concept of a frontier, a moving boundary that defined civilization and circumscribed the Wild West, was not new — though the idea that it made Americans unique was. Turner's paper is reprinted in its entirety, followed by articles by three "New Western" historians who bring the dialogue up to the present day by applying modern concerns to this long-standing issue. The last selection looks forward, asking what Turner's ideas mean for America as we head into the twenty-first century.
Series: Historians at Work
Paperback: 132 pages
Publisher: Bedford/St. Martin's; First Edition edition (April 16, 1999)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0312183097
ISBN-13: 978-0312183097
Product Dimensions: 6 x 0.3 x 9 inches
Shipping Weight: 6.4 ounces
Average Customer Review: 4.3 out of 5 stars See all reviews (12 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #432,357 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #382 in Books > History > Historical Study & Educational Resources > Historiography #1799 in Books > Textbooks > Humanities > History > Europe #15482 in Books > History > World
Wisconsin History Professor Frederick Jackson Turner came up with the "Frontier Thesis," the idea that it was the frontier that was the most important factor in shaping the American nation. Turner linked American democracy, nationalism, individualism, as well as physical and social mobility to how pioneers faced the frontier as they moved the boundaries of the United States westward. Richard W. Etulain presents four essays responding to Turner's Frontier Thesis and the question "Does the Frontier Experience Make America Exceptional?"Richard White's essay compares and contrasts how Turner and Buffalo Bill Cody interpreted the closing of the West at the end of the 19th-Century. White sees these narratives as having some elements in common but ultimately offering competing narrative explanations. In her essay Glenda Riley notes that Turner clearly ignored women from his story of the Frontier and outlines what he may have missed as a result. Martin Ridge focuses on the influence of Turner's thesis and characterizes Turner as sort of the high priest of American exceptionalism. Finally, Donald Worster notes that historians have essentially dismissed Turner's theory since the 1950s and considers what appropriate interpretation should be offered. Worster argues that historians should return to the interpretation offered by Walter Prescott Webb, who considered the West as an evolving place separate from what was happening in the big cities on each coast.I have always considered Turner's "Frontier Thesis" to be the prime example of historiography when it comes to introducing the concept to students. From talking to students it is clear that the Frontier Thesis has not been taught in schools for years, which is a shame because since the thesis so eminently debatable, as this collection of essays proves, it remains the perfect way of making students aware that what we teach as history is a collection of arguments rather than the "true" story of what "really" happened. As such, this volume is a useful source of alternative theories as well as insights into the strengths and weaknesses of Turner's ideas.
As a long time student of American history, this book ranks high on my list of must-haves. Starting with Frederick Jackson Turner's original lecture given in 1893, the book goes on to provide reactions from more current western scholars. Scholar Martin Ridge gives us an easily understood briefing of Turner's ideas, adding his skills as a communicator to Turner's established ideas. Otherwise, the book can be seen as a telling representation of how certain intellectuals in our society go about trying to make names for themselves by accusing previous generations of breaking currently popular taboos.Glenda Riley's take on Turner is that he dismisses the contributions of women. Then on the last page of her article, she admits that Turner did publish a study of pioneer's children in 1926 that includes an account of the success of women such as Jane Addams and Carrie Chapman Catt. Ridge nullifies her article further in a single stroke as he explains that Turner's writings were written for wide audiences, and were meant to be understood as generalities, not anecdotally.Patricia Nelson Limerick resorts to shock value to make a name for herself, as she refers to "white" people as an "odd" category, and claims that Turner's use of the term "frontier" is racist. She tries to close the book on all further discussion by saying flat out that Turner is "wrong," and she evidently knows that by using politcially charged words like "racist," she can get more bang for her buck. What she doesn't get around to explaining is that if women and minorities are equally responsible for the conquest of the west as are white men, which is something she desperately wants us to believe, then they must also be equally responsible for the defeat and removal of Indian Tribes from their previously held land, which is probably something she does not want to acknowledge.Donald Worster attempts to change the whole debate from a concept of the West being a changing frontier, to a study of the West as a geographical place. He claims that this geographical area includes the Dakotas, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma and Texas, and everyplace west of there and his evidence is that, "I know it in my bones." He says he could never understand the west as Turner did, as a process in motion.The value of this book is that it brings to light many interesting and debatable theories about our common American heritage. I hope that our systems of higher education will allow equal time to both sides of such debates in the future.
Does the Frontier Experience Make America Exceptional? (Historians at Work) Exceptional Service, Exceptional Profit: The Secrets of Building a Five-Star Customer Service Organization Make Easy Money Online: Follow in my footsteps and replace your 9-5 job in 30 days with no prior experience (How to make money online, Work less, Make money from home, Build a business) Romance: INSPIRATIONAL FRONTIER ROMANCE: A Place to Call Home (Pioneer Christian Romance Novelette) (Inspirational Western Frontier Romance) The Collected Short Stories of Louis L'Amour: Unabridged Selections from The Frontier Stories: Volume II: What Gold Does to a Man: The Ghosts of Buckskin Run: The Drift: No Man's Mesa Communication the Cleveland Clinic Way: How to Drive a Relationship-Centered Strategy for Exceptional Patient Experience Becoming an Exceptional Executive Coach: Use Your Knowledge, Experience, and Intuition to Help Leaders Excel Facts the Historians Leave Out: A Confederate Primer Herodotus and Sima Qian: The First Great Historians of Greece and China: A Brief History with Documents (Bedford Cultural Editions Series) The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past Historians' Fallacies : Toward a Logic of Historical Thought Cornelius Nepos: On Great Generals. On Historians. (Loeb Classical Library No. 467) What If It Does Work Out?: Turn your passion into cash, make an impact in the world and live the life you were born to. Software Reusability. Volume II: Applications and Experience (Acm Press Frontier Series) The Social Work Experience: An Introduction to Social Work and Social Welfare (6th Edition) (Connecting Core Competencies) Creating Exceptional Color with Acrylics: How to Make Color Choices That Will Take Your Painting to a New Level Outstanding!: 47 Ways to Make Your Organization Exceptional How Does Your Brain Work (Rookie Read-About Health) Electricity (How Does My Home Work?) How Does Wifi Work? (High-Tech Science)
