

Series: Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies
Paperback: 480 pages
Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company; 1st edition (April 1, 1999)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0393317552
ISBN-13: 978-0393317558
Product Dimensions: 6.2 x 1.5 x 9.3 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.1 out of 5 stars See all reviews (2,243 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #680 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #1 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Human Geography #1 in Books > Science & Math > Agricultural Sciences > Crop Science #1 in Books > Textbooks > Social Sciences > Geography

I think some of the reviewers here didn't read the book closely enough to understand the context of some of Diamond's arguments. He never says that biogeographical effects are the ONLY causes history. His main purpose is the search for the ultimate, extremely general causes for the broadest of trends in human history and prehistory.By the time the Mongols roared across Asia, or the Moguls invaded India, many cultures around the world already changed so much that bioregional factors, though seminal in the creation of these broadest trends, weren't nearly as important as the political, religious and economic ones. He is not ignoring religion and so on but, he states plainly several times that isn't his focus. He is looking for ultimate causes--before humans had extremely advanced mental concepts like religion.He also wanted to point out the devastating influence of disease on history. It was surely the European germs that did most of the conquering of Native Americans. The guns and horses were almost incidental. Later on, once Europeans had established themselves, then we can focus on economic and political systems. But we can't ignore the effects of the diseases unleashed on the Americas. These plagues gave the Europeans a very lucky boost that catapulted them beyond the wealth and power of China, India or the Middle East--long before the Industrial Revolution made this gap obvious.Another thing that some people seem to be having trouble with is his assertions about the native intelligence of tribal peoples around the world. (If you read the book, you notice that he is not just saying this about the New Guineans.)He takes pains to point out what he means by this. He not talking about some mysterious genetic superiority of tribal peoples.
In one compelling volume, the famous biologist Jared Diamond tackles the most important question of global history: Why did Europeans come to dominate the New World?This question has been answered by others before; Diamond's idea that Europe's geography is the cause ("geographical determinism") has also been proposed before. Any student of history can drag up a case or two of this thesis. Baron Montaigne, for example, proposed that Europe's primacy stemmed from its superior government, which could be derived directly from the coolness of its climate.The deep significance of this book is that Diamond's thesis is not simply idle speculation. He proves that the Eurasian land mass had by far the best biological resources with which to develop agricultural societies, and was thus more able to form large, coherent, and powerful social entities.To support this idea, Diamond introduces thorough set of well-researched data on what kinds of plants and animals are necessary to support a farming society. He investigates the biological resources available to potential farmers in all parts of the world. The people of Eurasia had access to a suite of plants and animals that provided for their needs. Potential farmers in other parts of the world didn't-- and so their fertile soil went untilled.After establishing this strong foundation, Diamond falls into repeating ideas about the formation of large-scale societies. These ideas, while unoriginal, are still compelling, and Diamond presents them in a very clear and well-written way.His other major original contribution comes when he discusses the diseases that helped the Old World conquer the New.
According to Diamond, four factors are responsible for all historical developments: 1) availability of potential crops and domestic animals, 2) the orientation of continental axis to facilitate the spread of agriculture, 3) transfer of knowledge between continents, and 4) population size.Diamond states that "those four sets of factors constitute big environmental differences that can be quantified objectively and that are not subject to dispute." Fair enough, but what *is* subject to dispute is that there might be some other factors at work. Thomas Sowell in Race and Culture does a good job of developing the thesis that the exchange of information among European cultures, facilitated by Europe's plentiful navigable rivers, was the key to Europe's technological and economic rise. David Landes in the Wealth and Poverty of Nations attributes China's conscious decision in the 1400's to isolate itself form other nations as the key event (decision) that caused it to lose it's technological advantage and fall behind Europe. (Diamond briefly touches on 15th Century China in the final chapter, but manages to boil this as well down to an accident of geography.)This is unfortunate, because the book contains a wealth of excellent material which is excellently explained. Many of the core causes which Diamond explores ring very true, and his points are persuasively argued. The connection between the development of agriculture and the subsequent unequal rise of military capability worldwide is very convincing. But convincing though they may be, reading these theories one can't shake the sneaking suspicion that Diamond is selectively presenting evidence which he's has found to support his previously drawn conclusion, and neglecting evidence which runs counter.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Guns,Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies | Summary Guns, Germs and Steel: The Fate of Human Societies Guns Danger & Safety 2nd Edition: An Essential Guide In Firearm Ammunition, Loading, Shooting, Storage and Safety (Guns, Guns & Ammo, Ammunition, Hunting, ... Loading, Targets, Handguns, Gun Storage) Badass LEGO Guns: Building Instructions for Five Working Guns Nursing: Human Science And Human Care (Watson, Nursing: Human Science and Human Care) Fates and Traitors: A Novel of John Wilkes Booth Fates and Furies: A Novel The Essential Grizzly: The Mingled Fates of Men and Bears The Other Wes Moore: One Name, Two Fates Lexicon Devil: The Fast Times and Short Life of Darby Crash and the Germs Germs Make Me Sick! (Let's-Read-and-Find-Out Science 2) When Germs Travel: Six Major Epidemics That Have Invaded America and the Fears They Have Unleashed Germs: Biological Weapons and America's Secret War Silent Travelers: Germs, Genes, and the Immigrant Menace The Gospel of Germs: Men, Women, and the Microbe in American Life Germs! A Coloring Book for Sick People Germs (Rookie Ready to Learn) Germs Are Not for Sharing (Board Book) (Best Behavior Series) Human Caring Science: A Theory of Nursing (Watson, Nursing: Human Science and Human Care)