

Hardcover: 304 pages
Publisher: Henry Holt and Co.; Mti edition (April 7, 2015)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1627795073
ISBN-13: 978-1627795074
Product Dimensions: 7.8 x 1.1 x 9.4 inches
Shipping Weight: 2.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (1,386 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #1,088 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #19 in Books > History > Americas > United States > State & Local

This volume is actually written by David Fisher (who is clearly and honestly credited) in a crisp and uncluttered, but sometimes dramatic, Bill O'Reilly style. O'Reilly himself attaches his name to the title and contributes a pithy (less than 3-page) introduction. Thereafter, biographical accounts (with appropriate, relevant historical background) are provided for Daniel Boone, David Crockett, Kit Carson, Black Bart, Wild Bill Hickok, Bass Reeves (a lesser-known figure, but a fearless and tenacious African-American deputy marshall, here presented -- in a bit of myth-making of its own -- as a possible model for the fictional Lone Ranger), George Armstrong Custer, Buffalo Bill & Annie Oakley, Jesse James, Doc Holliday (and the Earps), Billy the Kid (with speculation about the possibility he was not really killed by Pat Garrett but lived on as one "Brushy Bill"), and Butch Cassidy (along with the Sundance Kid). Interspersed among these accounts are six informative topical essays (3-6 pages each) titled thusly: "Dime Novels," "Up and Down Towns," "The Reality of an 'Indian Summer,'" "The American Indian: With No Reservation," "Shooting Down a Legend" (about quick-draw shootouts), and "A Moving Image: Creating the Wild West on Film." There is a bibliography, and the book is beautifully and copiously illustrated (both in b&w and color). [See NOTE at end of review.]Overall, these short, realistic depictions purport to debunk the myths and correct the mistruths attached to these famous folks.
This book repeats as fact some of the same old myths and lies that have plagued these characters for years (Hickok killed 36 people? Really? There have only been about a half dozen deaths actually documented) but then, it is written for a popular audience, not the serious researcher. It is exhausting, however, to once again see the same sloppy "research" reported as fact. This sloth extends to the internal narrative; the book routinely contradicts itself, which means the writer and editor are not only ignorant, but are also too lazy to proof their own material. Here's a novel suggestion: don't write a history book unless it contributes something new, especially when dealing with an area that has been well plowed by far better writers and far better researchers for many years. At the very least, hire a ghostwriter who has a little knowledge of the subject, will actually read what he has written, and goes a little deeper than Wikipedia when looking for source material. For this project, you might actually have to go outside New York City, God forbid, to find somebody who has a passing knowledge of the American West.All that being said, what is REALLY annoying is to see the same cavalier approach taken with the photos in the book. Doc Holliday was never photographed with a bowler hat, it was a joke composite put together by a photographer a few years ago as every Holliday researcher knows - yet there he is, bowler and all, in this book. Bill's other picture of Doc was actually the cover story of True West magazine a few years back, which went into great detail about the fraudulent nature of the image. Yet, what head shot does Bill say is that of Doc? You guessed it.
Bill O'Reilly's Legends and Lies: The Real West Bill O'Reilly's Legends and Lies: The Patriots The Real Book of Real Estate: Real Experts. Real Stories. Real Life The Bill Evans Trio - Volume 1 (1959-1961): Featuring Transcriptions of Bill Evans (Piano), Scott LaFaro (Bass) and Paul Motian (Drums) Lies, Damned Lies, and Science: How to Sort Through the Noise Around Global Warming, the Latest Health Claims, and Other Scientific Controversies (FT Press Science) Real Estate: 25 Best Strategies for Real Estate Investing, Home Buying and Flipping Houses (Real Estate, Real Estate Investing, home buying, flipping houses, ... income, investing, entrepreneurship) Real Estate: 30 Best Strategies to Prosper in Real Estate - Real Estate Investing, Financing & Cash Flow (Real Estate Investing, Flipping Houses, Brokers, Foreclosure) The Mystery at Jamestown (Real Kids, Real Places) (Real Kids! Real Places! (Paperback)) Japanese Tales and Legends (Oxford Myths and Legends) The Book of Legends/Sefer Ha-Aggadah: Legends from the Talmud and Midrash Kid Artists: True Tales of Childhood from Creative Legends (Kid Legends) Michael Jordan: Legends in Sports (Matt Christopher Legends in Sports) Kid Athletes: True Tales of Childhood from Sports Legends (Kid Legends) Star Wars Legends Epic Collection: The Old Republic Volume 1 (Epic Collection: Star Wars Legends) Legends & Lore of East Tennessee (American Legends) The Measure of the Magic: Legends of Shannara (Legends of Shannara Duology) Legends of Shannara Bearers of the Black Staff by Terry Brooks Unabridged CD Audiobook (Legends of Shannara) Babe Ruth: Legends in Sports (Matt Christopher Legends in Sports) Muhammad Ali: Legends in Sports (Matt Christopher Legends in Sports) Jackie Robinson: Legends in Sports (Matt Christopher Legends in Sports)