

Series: Best American
Hardcover: 752 pages
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (October 6, 2015)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0547485859
ISBN-13: 978-0547485850
Product Dimensions: 6 x 2.2 x 9 inches
Shipping Weight: 2.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.2 out of 5 stars See all reviews (51 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #16,869 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #1 in Books > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Genres & Styles > Short Stories #20 in Books > Literature & Fiction > United States > Anthologies #70 in Books > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Criticism & Theory

This collection of short stories proclaims to be the best American short stories of the past 100 years. It takes a lot of hubris to cull and choose stories published over a century and state, with surety, that these surpass all others in quality and attributes, The book is edited by Lorrie Moore, whose short stories I sometimes gravitate towards and sometimes don't connect with. The co-editor is Heidi Pitlor who edits an annual short story collection. On the whole, the stories selected for this collection are good, some are superb, and others left me shaking my head in puzzlement as to why they were included. It's easy to pull things apart but, for this review, I will focus on those stories I loved, some of which I may have read previously and others that are new to me but I will never forget.The collection is arranged chronologically and there is a short description of each time period with a focus on the types of stories that were prominent during that era. I found this helpful and learned a lot about what was published and who might have been influenced by whom. There are a total of 39 stories, the first published in 1917 and the last published in 2014. Of the 39, seven stand out high above the rest. A few of these are old friends and some of them I have never read before.Edna Ferber's story, 'The Day Old Dog', published in 1917, is very different from other stories of hers that I've read. It tells about a man's deathbed promise to his mother and, because of this promise - to take care of his sisters until they marry, he loses his own chance to marry and have a family. He continue to have dreams of the the life he may have led but they dissipate as time forces him head to head with reality.Nancy Hale published 'Those Are As Brothers' in 1942. I had never heard of her before reading this story. Written in the aftermath of World War II, the concept of shared terror is explored, along with the power of strength and connection.James Baldwin published 'Sonny's Blues' in 1958. It is about two African-American brothers who grow up in Harlem and appear to go in very separate directions after World War II. What touched me most in this story is its examination of the connections made without words - some through music, some through the collective unconscious, and some through inner promises we make to ourselves.Mona Simpson published 'Lawns' in 1986. It is a brilliant exploration of the impact of sexual abuse on an adolescent girl. As a clinical social worker, I have not read anything that comes close to examining the inner world of a child/woman trying to make sense of an irrational life.In 1995, Jamaica Kincaid published a story called 'Xuela'. In it, the birth date of an infant from Dominica corresponds to the day of her mother's death. The child spends her life wondering what her mother might have been like, what is the true essence of her father, and what comprises her own sense of self.'What We Talk About When We Talk About Anne Frank' is one of my favorite short stories. Published in 2012 by Nathan Englander, it addresses a 'ritual game' that exists in many jewish families. In this game, the family discusses who would be entrusted with their care and the care of their children if the Nazi's ever came to power again. In this story, two couples get together and the game leads to a startling realization for one of them.'Diem Perdidi' by Julie Otsuka, published in 2012 is another one of my favorite stories. 'Diem Perdidi' means 'I lost the day' in Latin. This story is the most poignant and poetic in the collection. Narrated in first person, the reader is privy to the losses and gifts of dementia.The stories in this book cover a variety of themes and topics. There does not appear to be a political bent, which I appreciate, and the 'political correctness' which is present in so much of today's collections does not appear to be present. For this, too, I am also thankful. It is obvious that the editors spent much time and thought choosing these stories and there are some gems in this collection.
Lorrie Moore and Heidi Pitlor who compiled this collection have undertaken a rather ambitious task: To select a representation of presumably the best stories of the last 100 years. The task becomes even more daunting when you consider the college textbook industry offers dozens of similar anthologies.My definition of an amazing story is that in one reading it has the âweight of a novel,â the complexity, density, and texture that you might find in a 300-page book. Such stories are evident in this collection: âThe Enormous Radioâ by John Cheever, âThe Whole World Knowsâ by Eudora Welty, âI Stand Here Ironingâ by Tillie Olsen, âSonnyâs Bluesâ by Sonny Baldwin, âThe Conversion of the Jewsâ by Philip Roth, âEverything That Rises Must Convergeâ by Flannery OâConner, âPigeon Feathersâ by John Updike, âWill You Please Be Quiet, Please?â by Raymond Carver, "Friend of My Youth" by Alice Munro, âCommunistâ by Richard Ford, âWhat We Talk About When We Talk About Anne Frankâ by Nathan Englander, âThe Semplica-Girl Diariesâ by George Saunders.There were some glaring omissions. For a collection that represents the last 100 years, Iâd want to see âA Good Man Is Hard to Findâ by Flannery OâConner, âThe Rich Brotherâ by Tobias Wolff, and âWhat We Talk About When We Talk About Loveâ by Raymond Carver.It seems the âcanonâ stories of some of the authors have been omitted in place of lesser-known ones, perhaps because the editors either thought their story selections were superior and/or they wanted the book to have some freshness to it and not simply recycle the âgreatest hits.âI think their strategy is successful. The collection is both fresh and contains dozens of stories that have âthe weight of a novelâ inside them.Perhaps Lorrie Moore is too modest to include one of her own stories in this collection. She needs to be in here. One of those ânovelâ stories I defined earlier is embodied by her masterpiece âReal Estateâ from her collection Birds of America. I wish that story were in this collection. In any event, this is a very successful compilation and I would consider using it for one of my college classes.
100 Years of The Best American Short Stories Every 100 Years - The Woody Guthrie Centennial Songbook: 100 Years - 100 Songs Italian Short Stories for Beginners, Volume 2 [Italian Edition]: 8 More Unconventional Short Stories to Grow Your Vocabulary and Learn Italian the Fun Way! Italian Short Stories for Beginners: 8 Unconventional Short Stories to Grow Your Vocabulary and Learn Italian the Fun Way! Spanish: Short Stories for Beginners: 9 Captivating Short Stories to Learn Spanish & Expand Your Vocabulary While Having Fun French Short Stories for Beginners: 9 Captivating Short Stories to Learn French and Expand Your Vocabulary While Having Fun Spanish Short Stories for Beginners, Volume 2: 8 More Unconventional Short Stories to Grow Your Vocabulary and Learn Spanish the Fun Way! Spanish Short Stories for Beginners: 8 Unconventional Short Stories to Grow Your Vocabulary and Learn Spanish the Fun Way! The Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway: Volume I (Short Stories (Simon & Schuster Audio)) Minecraft Kid's Stories, Book 2: A Collection of Great Minecraft Short Stories for Children, Minecraft Kid's Stories Minecraft: Silly Stories about Minecraft: Fun Short Stories for Kids (Children's Book: Cute, Bedtime Stories for Beginning Readers Book 6) Books for Kids: Chompy the Shark (Bedtime Stories For Kids Ages 4-8): Short Stories for Kids, Kids Books, Bedtime Stories For Kids, Children Books, Early ... (Fun Time Series for Early Readers Book 2) The Best American Short Stories 2016 The Best American Short Stories 2001 Writing Romance: The Top 100 Best Strategies For Writing Romance Stories (Romance Stories Book & Novel Writing Guide) Best of the Best from Hawaii: Selected Recipes from Hawaii's Favorite Cookbooks (Best of the Best State Cookbook) Best of the Best from Big Sky Cookbook: Selected Recipes from the Favorite Cookbooks of Montana and Wyoming (Best of the Best Cookbook Series) Best of the Best from the Deep South Cookbook: Selected Recipes from the Favorite Cookbooks of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama (Best of the Best Regional Cookbook) Best of the Best from Alaska Cookbook: Selected Recipes from Alaska's Favorite Cookbooks (Best of the Best Cookbook Series) A White Tea Bowl: 100 Haiku from 100 Years of Life